Sweet And Spirited

Hot Chocolate With A Boozy Twist

by Joni Falvey // January - February - March 2025

The winter months can be dreary at times, sending us on a quest for comfort – and what could be more soothing than a rich, delicious cup of hot chocolate? The name alone stirs up a sense of nostalgia – memories of playing in the cold followed by a steamy mugful that not only heated your hands but also warmed your heart. But there’s so much more to this nostalgic beverage, making it a delightful treat for anyone of any age, any time of year.

For thousands of years, chocolate has been revered as an invaluable, sacred, even magical treat. An incredibly complex substance and powerful elixir, chocolate contains compounds that boost mood and vitality; combat stress, anxiety, and pain; and release the feel-good neurotransmitter serotonin in the brain. No wonder the chocolate tree’s scientific name, Theobroma cacao, is ancient Greek for “food of the gods.” What other beverage tastes great, is filling in nature, and stimulates both mind and body?

The original recipe was a mixture of ground cocoa beans, water, wine, and chili peppers. It didn’t take long for some regions to begin heating the mixture and sweetening it with sugar. Eventually, milk was added, creating the creamy goodness we know and love today.

While you might have grown up using the terms hot chocolate and hot cocoa interchangeably, they are actually distinct beverages. Modern hot chocolate traces its roots back to the bitter drinking chocolate of the Maya and Aztecs. Made with melted chocolate nibs, sugar, and milk, it’s known for its rich, thick texture and dark, indulgent flavor.

Hot cocoa also incorporates milk and sugar, but relies on cocoa powder to deliver its chocolatey flavor instead of real chocolate. The result is a drink that’s lighter and less rich than hot chocolate, yet is much sweeter. Cocoa powder lasts longer than regular chocolate, which makes it a good option to keep on hand for making homemade hot cocoa.

Boozy hot chocolate concoctions are far from a modern creation – they’re a continuation of chocolate’s rich, revered history. From ancient drinking chocolate mixed with wine and spices to today’s creative spiked variations, the tradition lives on. But what spirits pair best with this deliciously warm treat? The options are endless. Bourbon tends to be the most popular partner. Its smooth, light flavor adds just the right touch of warmth, giving the drink a cozy and comforting feel. Whiskey, rye, or Irish whiskey bring complexity to hot chocolate, as their rich, oaky flavors perfectly complement the drink’s chocolatey sweetness, while brandy adds depth and fruitiness, making it an elegant hot chocolate choice for cold winter nights.

Dark or spiced rum can enhance the flavor of hot chocolate with its caramel, vanilla, and spice notes, creating a comforting and indulgent drink that excites the senses. For a bold twist on the traditional, combine tequila with a dash of cinnamon and chili pepper and transform your drink into a Mexican-style hot chocolate – an irresistible treat that will leave you craving more. And surprisingly, red wine also makes the list. As one of the original ingredients in hot chocolate, this pairing offers a rich, velvety flavor that is not to be missed.

Liqueurs are also a tasty addition, offering a delightful way to infuse your favorite warm beverage with slightly less-boozy options while adding a touch of indulgence. Their versatility opens up endless possibilities for creating unique and delicious variations of this beloved steamy treat.

For example, coffee liqueur beautifully complements the chocolate flavor of hot chocolate while adding a subtle hint of coffee bitterness and sweetness. This pairing is perfect for chilly winter days, offering a harmonious blend of cocoa’s sweetness and the liqueur’s boozy notes – it’s like a mocha fit for the gods!

Orange liqueurs like Cointreau or Grand Marnier can spike your simple hot chocolate into a boozy delight, blending citrusy brightness with rich chocolatey goodness. And for you true chocoholics, Crème de cocoa or chocolate liqueur are the ultimate additions – because what pairs better with chocolate than even more chocolate?

The best liquor to pair with hot chocolate ultimately depends on personal taste and the flavor profile you’re looking for. Don’t hesitate to experiment and have fun – mix and match different spirits, hot chocolate bases, and garnishes to create your perfect cozy concoction. Whether you’re crafting a boozy treat for chilly nights by the fire or indulging your sweet tooth any time of year, the possibilities are endless. And for those observing Dry January, hot chocolate on its own remains a timeless, satisfying classic that never disappoints. So, raise your mugs and toast to the ultimate winter indulgence – cheers to chocolatey comfort!

Joni Falvey

Owner of Broadsides & Brews, located at 223 S. White Street in Downtown Wake Forest. Follow on social media @broadsidesandbrews.