More Than a Present

Thoughtful Giving is About More Than What's in the Box

by Elizabeth Johnson // Fall 2026

It’s that time of year when many of us begin thinking about the holidays ahead. As Thanksgiving and Christmas approach, my thoughts naturally turn to the people who have enriched my life, and I begin searching for meaningful ways to express how much they mean to me.

There was a season in my life when I relied heavily on gift cards and premade gift baskets. While I’m sure they were appreciated, they required very little thought on my part, and in some ways the gift reflected that. I had convinced myself that choosing a truly thoughtful gift required far more time and energy than I had to give.

But over the years, I’ve discovered that’s simply not true.

For me, searching for the right gift has become a way of saying, “You’re important to me. You matter. I see you.” It isn’t about finding the most expensive item – it’s about finding something that truly reflects who that person is. Planning ahead also removes much of the stress of holiday shopping and allows me to spend more time enjoying the season instead of rushing through it.

Now I pay attention all year long. I listen for passing comments about a favorite author, a new hobby, a color someone loves, or something they admired but wouldn’t buy for themselves. I keep a running list in the Notes app on my phone so that when the holidays arrive, I already have ideas waiting. It’s amazing how much pressure disappears when you aren’t trying to find the perfect gift on December 23.

I’ve also learned that the best gifts reflect the recipient’s personality rather than the giver’s tastes or budget. A thoughtfully chosen $25 gift often means more than an expensive, impersonal one. A beautiful piece of locally made pottery in colors that complement my daughter’s home will bring her more joy than an expensive crystal vase that I happen to love.

Sometimes the search itself becomes part of the gift. There have been times when I’ve looked at dozens of possibilities before finally finding the one that made me think, “That’s exactly her,” or “He will love this.” In that moment, I know I’m no longer just buying something – I’m choosing a way to express how much that relationship means to me.

Choosing something made by a local artisan can add another layer of meaning. Every handcrafted piece has a story, and every purchase supports someone who has poured time, talent, and passion into creating it. Sometimes it’s that story that resonates with the recipient just as much as the gift itself.

Of course, not every meaningful gift comes wrapped in a box. Some of the most treasured gifts become shared memories. Imagine taking a cooking class with your sister to learn your grandmother’s homemade pasta recipe, spending an afternoon exploring a botanical garden with a dear friend, or surprising your parents with tickets to a concert featuring music from their younger years. Long after the day is over, those memories continue to grow in value.

I also think it’s important to consider the stage of life someone is in. Many older friends and family members are no longer interested in accumulating more things. In fact, they may be trying to simplify their homes. For them, I often choose gifts that can be enjoyed without adding clutter: a selection of beautifully scented handmade soaps; a candle in a favorite fragrance; a basket of favorite treats; or tickets to the theater, ballet, or a concert. The gift is enjoyed, the memory remains, and nothing has to find a permanent place on a shelf.

Once you’ve found the perfect gift, don’t overlook the presentation. Beautiful wrapping, a sprig of greenery tucked beneath a ribbon, or a handwritten note explaining why you chose that particular gift can transform a simple present into something unforgettable.

After all, years from now, people probably won’t remember how much you spent. They’ll remember how you made them feel. The most meaningful gifts say, “I know you. I appreciate you. I was thinking about you.” And that’s a gift that never goes out of style.

Elizabeth Johnson

Co-owner of The Cotton Company, a multi-vendor marketplace for unique gifts, art, home décor, and fashion.